Il n'est pas convenable de mendier sauf dans l'un des trois cas

3-149 (The compiler of the book narrated) that his father - may God be pleased with him - narrated that Sa’ed ibn Abdullah quoted Ibrahim ibn Hashim and Sahl ibn Zyad al-Razi, on the authority of Isma’il ibn Marar and Abdul Jab’bar ibn al-Mobarak, on the authority of Yunus ibn Abdul-Rahman, on the authority of some of his friends that Aba Abdullah as-Sadiq (MGB) said, “A man went to Uthman ibn Affan while he was sitting at the door of the mosque and begged for five Dirhams . He also asked Uthman to guide him towards benevolent people. Uthman pointed to a corner of the mosque where Al-Hassan (MGB), Al-Hussein (MGB) and Abdullah ibn Ja’far were sitting. The man went to them, greeted them and begged of them. Then Al-Hassan (MGB) and Al-Hussein (MGB) told him, ‘O so and so! It is not permitted to beg unless for one of three reasons: for a large amount of blood-money, heavy debt or extreme poverty. Why are you begging?’ The man said, ‘It is for one of these reasons.’ Then Al-Hassan (MGB) donated fifty Dinars . Al-Hussein (MGB) granted him forty-nine Dinars and Abdullah ibn Ja’far donated him forty-eight Dinars. Then the man left them and went back to Uthman. Uthman asked him, ‘Well! What did you do?’ The man said, ‘I begged of you but you gave me only a little bit, but did not ask me what I needed that for. However, when I begged of one of those long-haired people, he asked me what I was asking them for. He told me that it is not permitted for me to ask unless it was for one of three reasons. I told him my reason and he granted me fifty Dinars. The second man gave me forty-nine Dinars and the third man gave me forty-eight Dinars.’ Then Uthman said, ‘Where else could you find people like them. They have cut off all knowledge and have gathered all good and wisdom for themselves (‘Fatamul Ilm Fatman’).’”The compiler of the book - may God increase his honor - said, “What is meant by ‘Fatamul Ilm Fatman’ here is that they have cut off all knowledge from others and have gathered all of it for themselves.”

Un homme passa devant Uthman ibn Affan alors qu'il était assis à la porte de la mosquée et lui demanda. Uthman lui donna cinq pièces d'argent. L'homme demanda à être guidé, Uthman lui montra trois jeunes hommes et lui dit de les approcher. L'homme s'approcha d'eux, les salua et leur demanda. Al-Hasan et Al-Hussein (paix soit sur eux) lui dirent que la question ne devait être posée que pour l'un des trois: une dette écrasante, une blessure grave ou une grande pauvreté. L'homme choisit l'une des trois et Al-Hasan lui donna cinquante dinars, Al-Hussein lui donna quarante-neuf dinars et Abdullah ibn Ja'far lui donna quarante-huit dinars. L'homme repassa devant Uthman qui lui demanda ce qu'il avait fait. L'homme expliqua et Uthman commenta que ces jeunes hommes avaient acquis la connaissance et la sagesse. L'auteur de ce livre (qu'Allah soit satisfait de lui) a expliqué que "Ils ont acquis la connaissance et la sagesse" signifie qu'ils l'ont coupée des autres et l'ont gardée pour eux-mêmes.